The first two were good in studio and live, and the next three were horrible in studio and live, and that's as far as I've gone - are all of these supposed to be examples of good studio vs. bad live or is this video helping us sort the wheat from the chaff?
+1
+1
-1
Vote comment up/down
scruples (Short Spike)
Those are definitly bad performances from Tarja and Floor (#3,4) but they have their good performances too, just like any singer.
+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down
Grothesk (Long Spike)
I was surprised about the Amy Lee one...Evanescence seemed so over-produced and manufacturered that I wouldn't expect her to have a fine live set up. It seems to me that most all of them lived up to their studio selves.
I would have liked to see how well Chibi lived up to the live version of "Blue", but she typically doesn't growl.
+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down
UltimateX (Short Spike)
I didn't really hear much issue with any of these bands. Most of these ladies can sing quite well live. I'd like to hear any current pop singer try it instead of lip syncing.
+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down
Nakey (Site Administrator)
that's the point, these girls can actually sing.
+1
0
-1
Vote comment up/down
UltimateX (Short Spike)
Yeah, that's pretty much what I thought, but I wasn't sure if the video author was being a dick or something.
Comments
(Old Spike)
The first two were good in studio and live, and the next three were horrible in studio and live, and that's as far as I've gone - are all of these supposed to be examples of good studio vs. bad live or is this video helping us sort the wheat from the chaff?
(Short Spike)
Those are definitly bad performances from Tarja and Floor (#3,4) but they have their good performances too, just like any singer.
(Long Spike)
I was surprised about the Amy Lee one...Evanescence seemed so over-produced and manufacturered that I wouldn't expect her to have a fine live set up. It seems to me that most all of them lived up to their studio selves.
I would have liked to see how well Chibi lived up to the live version of "Blue", but she typically doesn't growl.
(Short Spike)
I didn't really hear much issue with any of these bands. Most of these ladies can sing quite well live. I'd like to hear any current pop singer try it instead of lip syncing.
(Site Administrator)
that's the point, these girls can actually sing.
(Short Spike)
Yeah, that's pretty much what I thought, but I wasn't sure if the video author was being a dick or something.